Chariot Learning
  • About
    • FAQ
    • Our Curriculum
    • Areas Chariot Learning Serves
  • Services
    • SAT & ACT Prep
    • SAT/ACT TestFlip
    • Academic Coaching
    • Subject Tutoring
    • Strategic Reading Club
    • Proctored Practice Tests
    • GRE Prep
    • College Essay Coaching
    • Roots2Words
  • Calendar
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Resources
  • Contact
April 20, 2020 by Mike Bergin

Who Benefits from Test Optional Policies?

After weeks of hearing speculation, misinformation, and consternation about the future of the SAT and ACT in admissions, I need to share my thoughts on the matter of test optional policies. This article was first published on LinkedIn but found its way back home.

COVID-19 has changed the world in more ways than we can count. Certainly, the American education system will never be the same again. Not only have we all become intimately acquainted with the agony and ecstasy of online learning (can’t say teaching because not everyone is doing that) but the traditional path to college seems to be meandering through uncharted territory. A number of schools have explored test optional or test flexible admissions policies, but the current crisis (and a couple of cancelled test dates) seem to have triggered a flood of interest in removing test scores from the admissions equation.

But if we accept the premise that test optional schools consider some students fairly in the absence of standardized test scores, does that mean that ALL applicants to such a school will be considered fairly without test scores?

In most cases, the answer is a resounding NO.

The open secret among higher ed professionals is that all colleges and universities–from the most exclusive Ivy to easiest admits–have always been selectively test optional. The stars of the big money sports teams simply don’t have to deliver the same numbers as the rest of us, nor do certain other cohorts of college applicants. Who, then, are test optional policies intended for?

RECRUITED STUDENTS

Many high schoolers who excel in either popular (like basketball and football) or rare (like crew or fencing) sports attract attention from college coaches. Standouts in certain other activities may receive similar interest. When a coach or someone with equivalent influence advocates for an applicant, that student often benefits from both a lower standard for grades and test scores as well as greater certainty upon meeting established requirements. Higher test scores definitely help–particularly because that frees the coach to spend favor on a different applicant–but highly coveted candidates receive a lot more leeway than the rest.

STUDENTS FROM UNDERREPRESENTED GROUPS

I like to look at the Admissions team at a school as party planners, not so much as organizers of a four (or more) year bacchanal, but more as considerate hosts that want to assemble the most interesting and engaged cohort possible. Diversity is not just desirable but necessary for a vibrant campus community. Thus, admissions folks go out of their way to ensure that each incoming class encompasses the full range of national and international representation across every axis possible:

— country or state of origin
— gender
— race/ethnicity
— intended major
— socioeconomic class
— first-generation status
— religious and political affiliation

Every one of these factors can prove advantageous for applicants who don’t fit the mold of a school’s general population. For example, consider an institution like Cornell University that draws the bulk of its class from the Northeastern U.S., particularly New York; an applicant from North Dakota is likely to stand out. Don’t assume, though, that test optional policies automatically increase minority representation at a school; Andrew Belasco and his colleagues noted in the study The Test-Optional Movement at America’s Selective Liberal Arts Colleges: A Boon for Equity or Something Else? that the only real metric (apart, ironically, from average test scores) that increases after the implementation of test optional policies is the number of applications:

LEGACIES AND FULL-PAY STUDENTS

Regardless of their non-profit status, colleges and universities are economic enterprises. Very few institutions boast billion dollar endowments, which means that admissions policies, no matter how idealistic, cannot ignore financial considerations. Private universities, and increasingly public universities, are “tuition-driven” more than you’d think. You may not get someone from the Admissions office to admit this, but applicants who indicate that they will pay full tuition are very, very desirable–and will be even more so for the next few admissions cycles.

Equally enticing are applicants with strong legacy connections, not just because they already feel like part of the family but because legacies tend to become generous alumni. The influence of money may feel a bit unseemly, but, in an environment of constrained resources, every applicant who doesn’t need financial aid frees up support for those who do.

Most nationally-known colleges receive many more applications–sometimes ten to fifteen times more–than they have available seats. The challenges of sorting a homogeneous mass of overachievers with equally exceptional grades, myriad extracurriculars, and poignant essays become that much more intractable without the one metric designed specifically to rank students across all high schools along the spectrum of academic rigor and relative grade inflation or deflation. That’s why it would be naive to believe that traditional applicants can get away without submitting SAT and ACT scores.

The margin of error for selecting the right number of applicants who will both show up for the beginning of freshman year and do well enough to return the following year has always been slim for colleges and universities. Heightened competition, demographic shifts, changes to NACAC admission rules, and COVID-19 chaos have combined to create the most challenging environment in recent memory for schools. Test optional policies tend to increase the number of applicants, which can be the difference between life or death for struggling schools.

But eliciting applicants without test scores is hardly the same as accepting applicants without test scores. Outside of open admission or highly unselective schools, applicants without test scores are often admitted at lower rates than their score reporting peers. Little wonder such a high percentage of applicants still submit test scores at competitive test optional schools. Plus, merit aid still depends on scores even at most test optional schools, and homeschooled students still require standardized tests to put their educations in context. Last but certainly not least, schools that have never had to worry about eliciting enough applicants–namely, all the most popular schools in the nation–will probably still rely heavily on test scores, no matter what they say.

For the time being, then, accept that everyone involved in the college admissions process has little to no idea of what the future holds for the high school graduating class of 2020, let alone the class of 2021 or beyond. Colleges that adopt test optional policies under these conditions are reacting to issues far-removed from the standard (questionable) explanation of increasing equity and access. Don’t allow the atmosphere of panic to infect you. If we ever achieve a new “normal” in college admissions, we can hope for a clearer vision of what test optional really means. Until then, don’t naturally assume that test optional applies to you. In all likelihood, it doesn’t, and assuming otherwise could be a costly mistake.

admissions test scores test-optional

Previous articleStatus of the June 2020 SAT and ACTNext article Chariot Learning Teachers Rocking Remote Instruction
Mike Bergin
Tens of thousands of students a year prep for the SAT & ACT through programs Mike Bergin created or organized. After more than 25 years of intensive experience in the education industry, he's done it all as a teacher, tutor, director, curriculum developer, blogger, podcaster, and best-selling author. Mike founded Chariot Learning in 2009 to deliver on the promise of what truly transformative individualized education can and should be.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Helping high schoolers with tests, school, and life is what Chariot Learning is all about. Let us know how we can help you!

Latest Posts

  • What Does ‘Smart’ Mean in the 21st Century
  • How to Read Percentiles
  • Do SAT & ACT Subscores Matter?
  • Evaluating College ROI
  • What to Read This Summer

What is TestFlip?

Learn about the ultimate in self-directed supplemental SAT/ACT prep, powered by Chariot Learning:

  • Be patient when becoming someone you haven
    by chariotlearning 6 days ago
    Be patient when becoming someone you haven't been before.
  • Do not waste time thinking about what you could have done differently. Keep your eyes on the road ahead and
    by chariotlearning 2 days ago
    Do not waste time thinking about what you could have done differently. Keep your eyes on the road ahead and
  • When someone says you can
    by chariotlearning 2 weeks ago
    When someone says you can't do it, do it twice and take pictures!
  • You have no idea what you can "survive" until you have no choice!
    by chariotlearning 2 weeks ago
    You have no idea what you can "survive" until you have no choice!
  • Success is liking yourself, liking what you do, and liking how you do it. Here
    by chariotlearning 3 weeks ago
    Success is liking yourself, liking what you do, and liking how you do it. Here's to your success!
  • Life is about
    by chariotlearning 2 weeks ago
    Life is about 'not knowing' and then doing something anyway. Get good at it!
  • Being intelligent is not a felony but may get you in trouble anyway ;)
    by chariotlearning 1 week ago
    Being intelligent is not a felony but may get you in trouble anyway ;)
  • Set goals that are *almost* out of reach.
    by chariotlearning 1 week ago
    Set goals that are *almost* out of reach.

Subscribe to Mike’s Podcast

Subscribe to Tests and the Rest

PARENT GROUP AND NEWSLETTER

Are you an Upstate New York parent with questions about college admissions, testing, and scholarships? The Upstate NY College Conversations Facebook group is for you. Join today!

And also sign up for College Road, our free email newsletter delivering expert educational advice, test news, admissions action steps, special offers, and more.

Upcoming Events

  1. SAT/ACT Extended Class – Summer Mornings 2022

    July 6 @ 10:00 am - 12:00 pm
  2. SAT/ACT Online Flipped Class – July 2022

    July 6 @ 6:00 pm - 8:00 pm
  3. Practice SAT – Brighton (7/8/22)

    July 8 @ 10:00 am - 2:00 pm
  4. Practice ACT – Pittsford Library (7/12/22)

    July 12 @ 10:00 am - 2:00 pm
  5. SAT/ACT Extended Class – Summer Evenings 2022

    July 12 @ 6:00 pm - 8:00 pm

View All Events

Testimonials

It was great learning his secret tricks on how to score better – and the not so secret trick of practice, practice, practice! He improved our scores by 3-4 points, and we were very satisfied and happy with the final result.

Emma & Sara, Pittsford students

Read more testimonials...
© 2022 Chariot Learning, LLC. All rights reserved.