Chariot Learning
  • About
    • FAQ
    • Our Curriculum
    • Areas Chariot Learning Serves
  • Services
    • SAT & ACT Prep
    • SAT/ACT TestFlip
    • Academic Coaching
    • Subject Tutoring
    • Strategic Reading Club
    • Proctored Practice Tests
    • GRE Prep
    • College Essay Coaching
    • Roots2Words
  • Calendar
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact
July 21, 2021 by Mike Bergin

Stop the Obsession with College Rankings

In response to a new re-evaluation of the criteria for popular college rankings, I was moved to write something of a rebuttal on LinkedIn, which is shared in its entirety below. For the sake of our community and the families and educational partners we serve, allow me to add some further thoughts:

  • Our long national obsession with U.S. News & World Report college rankings has become unhealthy and unproductive in the effort to connect students with their best-fit schools.
  • Focusing with tunnel vision on the most selective 100 colleges ignores thousands of potentially better options.
  • Selectivity does not necessarily guarantee either specific educational quality or suitability.
  • Most of my colleagues–educators, school counselors, and educational consultants–care much more about basing school choice on student values, interests, goals, and restraints than which colleges rank highest in easily-gamed lists.

 

What is Really Wrong with College Rankings?

Generation after generation of ambitious college applicants (along with their parents, counselors, and school admins) have obsessed over the popular college rankings, meticulously poring over a map that presumes to chart the path to the loftiest pinnacles of academia and access. U.S. News & World Report has delivered the most influential rankings of “Best Colleges” for so long that its name and remaining relevance has become synonymous with school stratification.

Yet, despite the enduring popularity and influence of the U.S. News & World Report, the paradigm invites critics from all sides. Malcolm Gladwell, for example, has been trying to unravel what the rankings really tell us for over a decade. In a 2011 article in The New Yorker, he outlined the ideological prejudices and priority of selectivity over efficacy or education excellence implicit in the rankings. He also noted how surprised those who managed the rankings were that college presidents began deliberately gaming the positions of their schools in the U.S. News ranking, “as proof of their management, or as proof that they’re a better school, that they’re a good president.”

A decade later, Gladwell revisited the rankings in his appropriately-titled podcast, Revisionist History. In a two-part series, Lord of the Rankings and Project Dillard, Gladwell and his team endeavored to, as a “public service” to listeners, to “hack the algorithm and discover the dirty little secret of the rankings game.” What did they find? In the apt words of a writer from the United Negro College Fund, the rankings appear to have a clear bias in favor of schools with an obvious cross-section of attributes:

  • Have larger endowments
  • Have mostly white student bodies
  • Charge higher tuition rates
  • Keep student selection as small and narrow as possible

Wealth, class, race, and prestige drive the popular college rankings. Why, then, are so many individuals and organizations who ostensibly want to see more accurate academic analyses and a more level playing field for underprivileged, underrepresented groups focusing on, of all things, test scores??

A consortium representing something called New America’s Higher Education Team issued An Open Letter to The Editors of US News and World Report’s Best Colleges Rankings to request an end to the practice of using average SAT and ACT scores of incoming students to calculate the Best Colleges rankings:

“Using average scores of incoming students to rank an institution has never made sense, but is even more preposterous during a deadly pandemic. The Best Colleges ranking has been the leading college rankings publication for years, and its impact on consumers and institutions alike cannot be overstated.”

The signatories, who include classic opponents of academic standards alongside individuals and organizations who have historically found themselves on the right side of educational issues, trot out misleading statistics, erroneous interpretations of research, and a plea to consider the state of the world in spring of 2020 in an effort to instigate a meaningless change to meaningless rankings.

It’s unfortunate to see so much energy poured into superficialities like popular college rankings when the majority of American college applicants–especially underrepresented minority groups and first-generation students–need better K-12 public education, clear academic standards for success, and stronger financial support to make the most of the opportunities higher education can unlock. This persistent focus on both highly selective colleges and the single most objective standard in admissions ignores the real issues underlying education.

The U.S. News & World Report and similar ranking systems speak to selectivity, which has little in modern higher education to do with general or specific academic excellence. Those who throw their support behind these rankings in order to further a crusade against standards do a great disservice to those they purport to represent.

admissions equity standardized tests standards

Previous articleGraphs on SAT and ACT ReadingNext article Building the Habit of Success
Mike Bergin
Tens of thousands of students a year prep for the SAT & ACT through programs Mike Bergin created or organized. After more than 25 years of intensive experience in the education industry, he's done it all as a teacher, tutor, director, curriculum developer, blogger, podcaster, and best-selling author. Mike founded Chariot Learning in 2009 to deliver on the promise of what truly transformative individualized education can and should be.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Helping high schoolers with tests, school, and life is what Chariot Learning is all about. Let us know how we can help you!

Latest Posts

  • Growing That Growth Mindset
  • How Fair is Test Optional?
  • Why Reading Skills Matter
  • Sal Khan on Testing, Admissions, and Equity
  • Do Flipped Classrooms Work?

What is TestFlip?

Learn about the ultimate in self-directed supplemental SAT/ACT prep, powered by Chariot Learning:

  • How you respond to failure will either make you or break you.
    by chariotlearning 8 hours ago
    How you respond to failure will either make you or break you.
  • The most effective way to do it is to do it!
    by chariotlearning 4 days ago
    The most effective way to do it is to do it!
  • What kind of reader are you? http://ow.ly/14g050J1CP0
    by chariotlearning 2 weeks ago
    What kind of reader are you? http://ow.ly/14g050J1CP0
  • Keep making progress!
    by chariotlearning 2 days ago
    Keep making progress!
  • Have you given yourself permission to excel?
    by chariotlearning 2 weeks ago
    Have you given yourself permission to excel?
  • Your life if controlled by what you focus on. Focus on greatness this week!
    by chariotlearning 2 weeks ago
    Your life if controlled by what you focus on. Focus on greatness this week!
  • Maybe life isn
    by chariotlearning 1 week ago
    Maybe life isn't about avoiding the bruises...
  • The world is changed by your example, not your opinion.
    by chariotlearning 6 days ago
    The world is changed by your example, not your opinion.

Subscribe to Mike’s Podcast

Subscribe to Tests and the Rest

PARENT GROUP AND NEWSLETTER

Are you an Upstate New York parent with questions about college admissions, testing, and scholarships? The Upstate NY College Conversations Facebook group is for you. Join today!

And also sign up for College Road, our free email newsletter delivering expert educational advice, test news, admissions action steps, special offers, and more.

Upcoming Events

  1. Practice ACT – Fairport Library

    May 21 @ 10:00 am - 2:00 pm
  2. Free Practice ACT (5/22/22)

    May 22 @ 10:00 am - 2:00 pm
  3. Free Practice SAT (5/28/22)

    May 29 @ 10:00 am - 2:00 pm
  4. June SAT (Official Test)

    June 4 @ 8:00 am - 1:00 pm
  5. Free Practice ACT (6/5/22)

    June 5 @ 10:00 am - 2:00 pm

View All Events

Testimonials

Working with Chariot Learning was the best preparation choice we could have made. Robert's test scores increased by nearly 50 percentile points. Plus he learned reading and writing skills that he was able to apply immediately in school. Thanks so much!

Bob & Sarah, Brighton parents

Read more testimonials...
© 2022 Chariot Learning, LLC. All rights reserved.